Amish Peanut Butter Cream: Amazing No-Bake Pie

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Amish peanut butter cream has always felt like a warm hug on a plate to me. I remember my aunt making this dessert every summer when I was a kid. The kitchen would fill with the sweet, nutty aroma, and the anticipation of that smooth, creamy filling layered with crumbly peanut butter goodness was almost unbearable! It’s more than just a pie; it’s pure comfort food. This recipe is my go-to for sharing that nostalgic taste, and I’m so excited to show you how easy it is to recreate this classic treat. Let’s get baking this delicious Amish peanut butter cream recipe!

What is Amish Peanut Butter Cream?

Amish peanut butter cream is a delightful dessert that captures the essence of simple, wholesome baking. It’s essentially a no-bake pie or cream dessert featuring layers of smooth, homemade vanilla pudding and a sweet, crumbly peanut butter mixture, all nestled in a crisp pie crust. Often referred to as an Old fashioned Amish peanut butter cream, this treat embodies the values of community and comfort food so central to Amish culture. What makes it truly unique is the perfect balance between the creamy, rich pudding and the slightly salty, sweet peanut butter crumbles, creating a taste sensation that’s both familiar and utterly irresistible. This Amish style peanut butter cream is a testament to how simple ingredients can create something truly extraordinary.

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream

This dessert is an absolute winner for so many reasons. Get ready to fall in love with this Easy Amish peanut butter cream!

It’s incredibly simple to make, even for beginners.
The combination of creamy pudding and peanut butter is pure bliss.
It’s a guaranteed crowd-pleaser for potlucks and parties.
You get that satisfying homemade taste without a lot of fuss.
The textures are amazing – smooth, creamy, and delightfully crumbly.
It’s quick to assemble, making it perfect for last-minute desserts.
This Homemade Amish peanut butter cream tastes just like grandma used to make.
It’s a comforting dessert that brings smiles to everyone’s faces.

Ingredients for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Gathering your ingredients is the first step to creating this delicious Amish peanut butter cream. You’ll need components for the pudding filling, the peanut butter crumbs, and the whipped cream topping. These Amish peanut butter cream ingredients come together to make a truly special dessert. The hot milk helps the pudding thicken beautifully, while the butter and vanilla add richness and that classic sweet flavor. For the crumbles, simple creamy peanut butter and powdered sugar work wonders to create that perfect texture. Finally, the heavy whipping cream, sugar, and vanilla come together for a light and airy topping that balances the richness of the filling.

Pudding Filling:
3 cups hot milk – essential for thickening the pudding
3 large egg yolks, beaten – adds richness and helps bind the pudding
1/2 cup sugar – for sweetness
4 tablespoons cornstarch – the primary thickener for a smooth texture
2 tablespoons all-purpose flour – complements the cornstarch for a creamy consistency
1/2 teaspoon salt – balances the sweetness
2 tablespoons butter – adds a lovely richness
1 tablespoon vanilla extract – for that classic sweet flavor
Peanut Butter Crumbs:
1/3 cup creamy peanut butter – the star of our crumb topping
3/4 cup powdered sugar – to sweeten and help form crumbs
Whipped Cream Topping:
1 to 1 1/2 cups heavy whipping cream – for a light and fluffy topping
1 tablespoon sugar – to sweeten the whipped cream
1 teaspoon vanilla extract – enhances the flavor of the cream
Other:
1 baked 9-inch pie crust – your base for this delightful dessert

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream

Follow these simple steps to create the best Amish peanut butter cream pie. This recipe breaks down how to make each component, from the luscious pudding to the delightful peanut butter crumbles and fluffy whipped cream, so you can easily assemble this incredible dessert. Getting the texture and flavor just right is key to achieving that authentic, comforting taste.

Preparing the Pudding

First, let’s tackle the creamy base. In a saucepan, whisk together the hot milk, sugar, cornstarch, flour, and salt until no lumps remain. Gradually whisk in the beaten egg yolks. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the mixture thickens beautifully – it should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon. This step is crucial for achieving a smooth, luscious pudding. For more tips on thickening agents, you can check out this guide on cornstarch and flour.

Making the Peanut Butter Crumbs

Next, create the irresistible peanut butter crumbles. In a small bowl, simply combine the creamy peanut butter and powdered sugar. Use a fork to mix them together until small, crumbly bits start to form. Don’t overmix; you want a texture that’s crumbly, not a paste. These crumbles add a wonderful texture and nutty flavor to our pie.

Whipping the Cream Topping

Now for the light and airy topping! In a chilled bowl, whip the heavy whipping cream with the sugar and vanilla extract. Use an electric mixer on medium-high speed until stiff peaks form. This means when you lift the beaters, the cream holds its shape. Be careful not to over-whip, or you’ll end up with butter! For more on achieving perfect whipped cream, consider this helpful tutorial.

Assembling the Pie

It’s time to bring it all together to create the perfect Amish peanut butter pie filling. Sprinkle about three-quarters of your peanut butter crumbs into the bottom of your baked 9-inch pie crust. Carefully spread the completely cooled pudding evenly over the crumbs. Finish by topping the pudding with the freshly whipped cream. Finally, sprinkle the remaining peanut butter crumbs over the whipped cream for a beautiful finish and added texture. This layering process ensures every bite is a perfect combination of flavors and textures. You can find great pie crust recipes on Allrecipes.

Pro Tips for the Best Amish Peanut Butter Cream

Achieving that perfect texture and flavor is all about a few key details. These tips will help you make the absolute best Amish peanut butter cream every single time. I’ve learned these tricks through trial and error, and they make a huge difference!

Always ensure your pudding is completely cool before assembling. A warm pudding will melt your whipped cream topping.
Don’t overmix the peanut butter crumbs; you want distinct crumbles, not a smooth paste.
Chill the pie for at least 2-3 hours. This allows the flavors to meld and the filling to set properly.

What’s the secret to perfect Amish peanut butter dessert cream?

The secret lies in the balance of textures and temperatures. Using hot milk for the pudding ensures it thickens smoothly, and chilling it thoroughly before assembly is crucial. The contrast between the cool, silky pudding and the slightly drier crumbs is what makes this Amish peanut butter dessert cream so divine.

Can I make Amish peanut butter cream ahead of time?

Yes, you absolutely can! You can prepare the pudding and the peanut butter crumbs a day in advance and store them separately in the refrigerator. Assemble the pie a few hours before serving to keep the crust crisp and the whipped cream fresh. For more make-ahead dessert ideas, explore our recipes section.

How do I avoid common mistakes with Amish peanut butter cream recipe?

A common pitfall is not cooling the pudding completely, which leads to a soupy dessert. Also, overmixing the peanut butter crumbs turns them into a sticky mess instead of delightful crumbles. Lastly, ensure your whipped cream is stiff before topping to prevent it from deflating.

Best Ways to Serve Amish Peanut Butter Cream

Serving this delightful dessert is almost as fun as making it! This pie is a showstopper on its own, but here are a few ways to elevate the experience. For a touch of elegance, consider a drizzle of chocolate ganache as an extra Amish peanut butter cream topping. It pairs wonderfully with the nutty sweetness. You could also serve it alongside a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream for a decadent treat. For a lighter option, a small side of fresh berries, like raspberries or strawberries, adds a lovely tart contrast to the richness of the pie.

Variations of Amish Peanut Butter Cream

While the classic pie is divine, there are so many wonderful ways to enjoy the flavors of Amish peanut butter cream. You can adapt this beloved dessert to suit different tastes and occasions. For instance, if you adore peanut butter cookies, consider using this creamy mixture as an Amish peanut butter cream for cookies, spreading it between two soft peanut butter cookies for a delightful sandwich. Craving a cake? This rich filling also makes for an incredible Amish peanut butter cream frosting for cakes. Just adjust the consistency slightly by adding a touch more powdered sugar or a bit of milk to make it more spreadable. You could even transform it into a decadent dip!

Cookie Sandwiches: Spread the cream filling between homemade or store-bought cookies for a delightful treat.
Cake Filling/Frosting: Adjust the consistency to use as a luscious layer inside or a rich frosting on cakes.
Dip: Mix a bit more peanut butter and powdered sugar into the cream for a dip served with fruit or pretzels.
Crustless Version: Skip the crust entirely and serve the pudding and crumb mixture in individual bowls for a lighter dessert.

Storage and Reheating Amish Peanut Butter Cream

Properly storing your delicious Amish peanut butter cream ensures it stays fresh and delightful for days. After it has chilled sufficiently, cover the pie tightly with plastic wrap or aluminum foil. It’s best stored in the refrigerator and will keep well for about 3 to 4 days. If you happen to have any leftovers (which is rare!), you can freeze individual slices for up to 3 months. Just wrap them securely in plastic wrap, then a layer of foil. When you’re ready to enjoy a frozen slice, thaw it overnight in the refrigerator. While this pie is best served chilled and doesn’t require reheating, if you’re serving a frozen slice, let it sit at room temperature for about 20-30 minutes to soften slightly. This dessert also makes a fantastic Amish peanut butter cream dip when served slightly chilled with graham crackers or fruit!

Frequently Asked Questions About Amish Peanut Butter Cream

Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy for the crumbs?

While creamy peanut butter is recommended for the best texture in the crumbs, you can use crunchy if that’s what you have on hand. Just be aware that the texture will be a bit different, with more distinct peanut pieces. The flavor will still be fantastic, making it a great option for an Amish peanut butter cream dip.

What’s the difference between Amish peanut butter cream and regular peanut butter pie?

The term “Amish peanut butter cream” often implies a more traditional, homemade style, focusing on simple ingredients and comforting flavors. While many peanut butter pies share similar components, the “Amish” designation suggests a recipe passed down through generations, emphasizing wholesome ingredients and a rustic charm. It’s the kind of dessert you might find at a community bake sale, embodying simple goodness. It’s not necessarily a distinct recipe but more of a style. For more on Amish cooking traditions, you can explore resources on Amish culture.

Can I use this as an Amish peanut butter frosting recipe?

Absolutely! This filling can easily be adapted into an Amish peanut butter frosting. For a cake, you’ll want to make the pudding slightly thicker by reducing the milk slightly or adding a bit more cornstarch. Once cooled, you can whip it with some additional powdered sugar and a touch more peanut butter to create a spreadable frosting. It’s a wonderful base for an Amish peanut butter cream frosting recipe that’s sure to impress. If you’re interested in cake decorating, check out our about me page for inspiration.

How long does Amish peanut butter cream last in the refrigerator?

This delicious dessert typically stays fresh in the refrigerator for about 3 to 4 days when stored properly. Make sure to cover it tightly with plastic wrap or aluminum foil to prevent it from absorbing other odors and to keep the crust from drying out. It’s best enjoyed within that timeframe to maintain its optimal texture and flavor. For more information on food storage, consult the USDA’s food storage charts.